Spreadsheets are excellent for analysis, calculation and flexible working. They become a weak operational system when several people need to change the same process, permissions differ, records must be auditable or one accidental edit can damage the result.
Warning signs include many emailed copies, hidden formula dependencies, macros nobody can maintain, repeated re-keying, unclear ownership and manual work to discover which row is current. Size alone is not the deciding factor; a small sheet can carry high risk while a large analytical model remains appropriate.
Do not jump straight to bespoke software. First simplify the process and remove fields or steps nobody needs. Then check whether an existing product, structured form, shared list, database feature or small automation solves the important weakness.
If a replacement is justified, define the users, decisions, validation, history, exports and failure handling before choosing technology. Keep an agreed migration and fallback route so the spreadsheet is not switched off before the new process is proven.