A website does not need replacing simply because it is a few years old. The useful question is whether it still helps the right people understand the business and take the next step.
Start with the problems. Can customers find the important services? Does the site work comfortably on a phone? Can the content be updated safely? Is it slow, insecure or tied to an unsupported platform? Are the domain, hosting and administrator accounts under your control? A short review of those points often shows whether the foundation is sound.
Focused improvement can be enough when the platform is supportable and the main problems are content, navigation, accessibility, performance or a small number of layouts. This preserves working parts and usually reduces cost and risk.
A redesign or rebuild makes more sense when important changes fight the current structure, the software is no longer supportable, ownership is unclear, or the site cannot meet the business’s current goals without repeated workarounds. Before replacing it, take a verified backup and record the domain, DNS, hosting, analytics, forms, content and integrations that must survive the move.
Ask for a recommendation that explains both routes. A good proposal should say what can be retained, what needs to change, what you will own and how the old site can be recovered if a launch does not go to plan.